Study Finds That Black Male Teachers May Face Bias From Classroom Evaluators

Only about 2 percent of America’s teachers are Black men. According to a new study, one reason for the small numbers may be that Black male teachers face bias from administrators who monitor classroom performance and give them poor evaluations. This, in turn, may lead to lower job satisfaction among Black male teachers, fewer promotions, and more Black men leaving the teaching profession.

The was co-authored by Jason Grissom, the Patricia and Rodes Hart Professor of Public Policy and Education at Vanderbilt University, and Brendan Bartanen, an assistant professor of education at the University of Virginia. They examined more than 460,000 classroom observations between the 2011–12 and 2018–19 school years in the state of Tennesse. Teachers in the state typically undergo between two and five observations each year, and the overwhelming majority are rated on 19 indicators of instruction, environment, and planning.

Women received higher evaluations than men. And Whites received higher evaluations than Blacks. As a result, Black men were the lowest-rated group. The Black-White gap is largest in schools where Black teachers are racially isolated and is partly explained by Black teachers’ propensity to be assigned less advantaged students within their schools. But even when comparing similarly credentialed teachers whose pupils achieved at about the same level, White and female teachers were rated higher than Black men.

The authors state that “at a time of growing interest in increasing teacher diversity, it is valuable to understand factors that may affect the work experiences of teachers who are already underrepresented in the classroom and potentially push them to exit the teaching workforce. Further investigation to understand the sources of these gaps is key to identifying solutions. Yet the presence of gaps across schools with so many different characteristics suggests the need for several next steps to address them to ensure that teachers are evaluated fairly.”

The full study, “Potential Race and Gender Biases in High-Stakes Teacher Observations,” was published in the Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. It may be accessed here.

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. HBCU Watch says:

    Why should anyone with an inkling of intelligence be even remotely surprised with these findings. Similar findings can be easily found in the the medical, legal, financial, higher education, and the real estate industry.

    The facts remain, the majority of White, Asian, Latino, etc. continue to view native born Black American males through a very negative and stereotypical under the guise of years of White American hegemonic miseducation.

  2. Mr. Mansur says:

    I can’t believe that hostility, discrimination, sexism is still the how black males are evaluated by the majority educators in the districts. It is demoralizing and criminal to have to see another black man be told that “you were pleasant and amenable to work with, but if I am being asked to honestly reflect on your performance as a teacher… I would not be a good option for you as a reference.” Time and time again. Something to this effect black men have to endure this. How does that even sound? I’ve comtemplated suicide.

Leave a Reply

Due to incidents of abuse and harassment that have occurred in the past, JBHE will not publish telephone numbers or email addresses of individuals in this space. If you want to contact someone in a particular article, we suggest you contact them directly not in an open forum.