Study Finds Minority Managers Who Hire Minorities Are Likely to Be Rated Less Competent

coloradouniversityA new study, led by researchers at the Leeds School of Business at University of Colorado at Boulder, included an experiment where hundreds of participants were asked to evaluate a fictional hiring decision by a manager in a corporate setting. Participants read a description of the hiring decision that included a photo of the manager that indicated his or her ethnic identity. The participants were then given a questionnaire about the hiring decision.

The results showed that minority managers were rated as less effective when they hired a minority applicant for the open position than minority managers who hired a White person for the post. For White managers, there was no difference in competency rating on whether they hired a minority or non-minority candidate.

The results led the authors to conclude that “for all the talk about how important diversity is within organizations, White executives aren’t rewarded career-wise, for engaging in diversity-valuing behavior, and non-White executives actually get punished for it.”

The authors write that “it’s risky for low-status group members to help others like them. And this can lead to minorities choosing not to advocate for other non-Whites once they reach positions of power, as they don’t want to be perceived as incompetent.”

The study, “Does Diversity-Valuing Behavior Result in Diminished Performance Ratings for Nonwhite and Female Leaders?,” was published on the website of the Academy of Management Journal. It may be accessed here.

Related Articles

2 COMMENTS

  1. Good afternoon. I am writing on behalf of the President/CEO of the National Urban League. We are interested in obtaining a copy of your study regarding minority managers hiring minorities. Could you possibly assist with this request?

    Thank you.

    Catherine Ortiz

    • There is information on accessing the study at the end of the article. Or, if you prefer, you can contact the authors directly.

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Yale University Commits $10 million Toward HBCU Partnerships

Yale University issued a formal apology three weeks ago regarding its historical ties to slavery. In response, the university has pledged $10 million towards an initiative that aims to expand collaboration with historically Black colleges and universities.

Gallup Survey Finds Black Students More Likely Than Their White Peers to Withdraw From College

A 2023 survey conducted by Gallup in partnership with the Lumina Foundation has found that 40 percent of currently enrolled Black students have considered stopping their coursework in the past six months, compared to 31 percent of White students.

Recent Books of Interest to African American Scholars

The Journal of Blacks in Higher Education regularly publishes a list of new books that may be of interest to our readers. The books included are on a wide variety of subjects and present many different points of view.

Nadine Barnett Cosby Appointed Quinnipiac University’s First-Ever Black Dean

"As the newly appointed dean of the School of Communications at Quinnipiac University, I am honored to lead a community of dynamic minds, where I aim to inspire innovation, amplify voices, and shape the future of communication education with passion and purpose," Dr. Barnett Cosby said.

Featured Jobs